As men and women age, their bones become more porous and fragile. Women are routinely screened for osteoporosis; men are not. In fact, recent research shows that women are three times more likely to be treated for thinning bones than men, even though men's hip fractures are known to be more likely to cause death.
In 2012, guidelines published by the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) identified osteoporosis as a major health issue in men because their risk of illness and death following a hip fracture is greater than for women. The VHA guidelines identified three groups of men at very high risk for fractures: those who had a previous hip fracture, men taking hormone (androgen) deprivation therapy (ADT) for prostate cancer or those on long-term steroid therapy.
But are men who are at additional risk for fracture actually getting evaluated and treated? Not really. Women are much more likely to be screened and treated for osteoporosis than men of the same age, researchers at the University of Washington found, concluding that, “Current guidelines are inadequate for identifying men who would benefit from osteoporosis evaluation and preventive treatment.” In this case, the sex discrimination works against men, they write.
Women entering menopause are routinely prescribed vitamin D and calcium supplements, and they are significantly more likely than men to be prescribed bisphosphonates.
Participants' fracture risk over the next decade was determined using the risk assessment tool FRAX. As they expected, fracture risk over the next 10 years increased with age in both men and women.
A fracture risk of three percent or greater puts a person over the minimum threshold for treatment with vitamin D and bisphosphonates, a class of drugs prescribed for osteoporosis. The team found that nearly half — 48 percent — of men between the ages of 75 and 79 years old who had only age as a risk factor for osteoporosis had a 10-year hip fracture risk of three percent or greater, making it clear how common osteoporosis is among men. Among men 80 years old and older, the fracture risk rose to 88 percent .
For men who had had a previous fracture or were taking hormone deprivation therapy for prostate cancer or were on long-term steroid therapy, the risk of fracture was far greater. This group had a 69 to 95 percent 10-year fracture risk of three percent or greater. Yet only 12 percent of all men in the study had their bone density tested with dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) bone density testing , compared with 63 percent of women. And only 18 percent of men had vitamin D levels in their blood tested, in stark contrast to the nearly 40 percent of women given the test.
Women entering menopause are routinely given vitamin D and calcium supplements (63 percent versus 20 percent), and they were significantly more likely than men to be prescribed bisphosphonates (44 percent versus four percent).
It's not clear why men in the U.S. do not get tested and screened for osteoporosis as they age the way women do. It may be because busy clinicians are unaware of the screening guidelines for men, or doctors may simply feel it necessary to prioritize other health concerns and conditions due to limited time with patients. Men, too, seem to be unaware they should be concerned about bone health as they age, even after they've had a broken hip.
The study is published in the Journal of Investigative Medicine.