Families experiencing economic difficulties whether from job loss, injury or health problems can turn to Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF). TANF is a federally funded, state-run benefits program, also known as welfare. It is designed to help families achieve independence after experiencing temporary difficulties by offering financial assistance.
Welfare programs are intended to ensure that members of society can meet basic human needs such as food and shelter. But it’s up to individual states to decide when and if to make these funds available. And that’s the hitch.
A national study by researchers at Ohio State University looked at the program between 2004-2016 and found a direct relationship between states that held back or limited cash assistance and the number of kids who ended up neglected and in the foster care system.
“States have a lot of discretion in how they use the block grants for TANF and that allowed us to see how differences between states — and changes in states over time — were linked to child protective services involvement and foster care,” Michelle Johnson-Motoyama, co-author of the study, said in a press release.
Assistance for a family of three can range from $170 in Mississippi to $923 in Alaska.
There can be big differences among states’ approaches to assistance. For instance, for a family of three assistance can range from $170 in Mississippi to $923 in Alaska. Some states limit cash benefits by instituting stricter restrictions and making it more difficult for people to apply for assistance. That’s why the researchers also looked at different state restrictions on TANF benefits and its connection to welfare outcomes. Examples of state restrictions included:
- Work requirements for mothers of children less than a year old
- Cutting off benefits earlier than the five years the federal government allows
It was children who bore the consequences of these restrictive policies. The numbers of kids placed into foster care because of neglect increased substantially, according to the Adoption and Foster Care Analysis and Reporting System and the National Child Abuse and Neglect Data System. The study found that restrictions on TANF access were associated with 44 additional neglect victims per 100,000 children and 22 additional children per 100,000 placed in foster care.
“That’s about 29,000 children who might have a different life trajectory if their family had more resources. I think we have a pretty strong case for why we should invest in families and support them to do their best at parenting,” Johnson-Motoyama, a professor of social work at The Ohio State University, said.
It’s up to individual states to decide when and if to make these funds available. And that’s the hitch.
The researchers were careful to be sure the relationship of TANF to increases in foster care and child neglect was not the result of other circumstances such as a rise in the number of social safety-net caseloads, the effects of the opioid epidemic or the number of women in prisons.
Rates of foster care and child neglect were not significantly affected by any of these factors. What mattered most was how restrictive a state’s welfare policy was.
The study is published in Health Affairs.