Is the move to restrict serving sizes of soda in NYC a bad idea or a bold way to begin tackling obesity? More >
Recovering from Head Trauma before Resuming Sports Is Critical
Doctors never take head injuries in sports lightly. The problem is that people may not realize what is at stake if they don’t allow themselves a full recovery before getting back to their regular routines. The risk is even greater for young athletes, who are especially likely to rush back into action.
A new case study tells the story of a young football player who suffered what’s known as second impact syndrome (SIS), which happens when a head second injury occurs before full recovery from the first. The outcome is often fatal.
The public has become more aware in recent years of the serious dangers of traumatic brain injuries, particularly over the long-term, since they can lead to chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a form of dementia that has stricken sports stars like Dave Duerson and Derek Boogaard. But the damage from head injuries in contact sports can occur on a much shorter term than this, and leave a young player with severe neurological deficits, particularly in the case of SIS.
The authors of the paper, the doctors who treated him, detail the struggle of a 17-year-old high school football player who experienced SIS. The young man sustained helmet-to-helmet impact from another player during a play. He complained of dizziness and visual problems soon after, but continued to play in the game. His symptoms, which also included severe headaches and fatigue, persisted for the next few days; on the fourth day he saw a doctor, who did a head CT scan. The scan didn’t show damage, but the doctor advised him not to play until all his symptoms subsided.
Unfortunately, the young man decided to return to practice the next day and took part in hitting drills. Over the course of the practice, he began to be slower standing up after hits, and finally collapsed and became unresponsive; he then suffered a seizure.
The patient was brought to the local ER and another CT scan showed that he had subdural hematomas (collections of blood) on both sides of his brain. He was then airlifted to a university hospital, where it was discovered that the pressure within his skull was very high from the hematomas and some swelling of the brain. The result of this was that certain parts of the brain were shifted in a downward direction (herniation); some areas of his brain became softened from the pressure. He was still barely responsive at this point.
Among the side effects of his injuries that were treated in the hospital were “hypotension, renal failure, sepsis, pneumonia, and temporary cardiac arrest.” When he was released, after 98 days, he still couldn’t walk or talk. Three years after the injuries, the authors of the report say he had regained most of his speech, but was still confined to a wheelchair and had certain persisting behavioral changes, like impulsiveness.
The take-home message of this case study is that athletes who sustain head injuries should not return to their sport until all their symptoms are completely gone – and erring on the side of caution by taking a little longer to return to the field is probably wise. The authors add that the headaches that patients may experience are likely a predictor of SIS, if he or she returns to playing before symptoms have totally subsided; it certainly was for the patient profiled here. The doctors also hope that cases like this will encourage coaches, parents, and physicians to be more attuned to the seriousness of head injuries, since they can lead to permanent damage – or, like SIS, may be fatal.
The case study was written by doctors at the Indiana University School of Medicine and the Northwest Radiology Network in Indianapolis. It is published in the Journal of Neurosurgery: Pediatrics.
January 4, 2013