The idea that feeding antibiotics to farm animals can fuel antibiotic resistance in bacteria that cause human disease is not just theory, it has already happened. A recent genetic analysis of one increasingly troublesome strain of MRSA reveals that it almost certainly started out in humans as a non-resistant strain, and then jumped to pigs, where it acquired resistance to methicillin and tetracycline as a result of the presence of these antibiotics in animal feed. These bacteria now infect both humans and animals.
ST398 started out as an antibiotic-sensitive bacterium whose natural host was humans. It was only after it spread to livestock that antibiotic resistance began to appear.
This is some of the best evidence to date that routine addition of antibiotics to animal feed does cause antibiotic resistance in disease-causing bacteria and that the practice poses a significant human health threat.
In 2003, a novel form of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus, the notorious MRSA superbug, called ST398 began to emerge in livestock and soon began infecting farm workers. It is estimated that in some regions of the Netherlands, ST398 accounts for 25 to 35% of all human MRSA cases and 12% of all cases in the entire country. But until now, it was presumed that pigs and/or other animals were the natural hosts of ST398.
Researchers from several institutions recently did such an analysis on 89 different isolates of ST398 from 19 countries spanning four continents. These isolates came from humans and animals and included both antibiotic-resistant and sensitive subtypes. The evolutionary tree that emerged showed that the most ancient of these bacteria were antibiotic-sensitive isolates from humans. These are almost certainly the forerunners of all the other bacterial isolates.
In other words, ST398 started out as an antibiotic-sensitive bacterium whose natural host was humans. It was only after it spread to livestock that antibiotic resistance began to appear in these bacteria.
Feeding antibiotics to meat animals leads to an increase in the animals' weight and makes meat less expensive to produce. But concerns that this practice causes a widespread increase in bacterial antibiotic resistance led the European Union to ban the feeding of all medically important antibiotics to livestock in 1998 and extend the ban to all antibiotics in 2006.
In the U.S., routine administration of antibiotics to livestock raised for meat remains standard practice. The U.S. has banned the use of certain antibiotics in poultry (fluoroquinolones such as Cipro) and has recently limited the use of one other class of antibiotic in livestock (cephalosporins). This still leaves many other antibiotics that can be and are routinely fed to livestock.
The current study offers some hard evidence that this practice is not in the best interest of public health.
An article on the genetic analysis of ST398 was published online by mBio.